I wonder whether Warsaw can manage to celebrate Independence Day without private fire support from people nobody asked to provide it.
I appreciate the gravity of the question. The answer determines the point of several arguments, a number of purchases and at least one profile picture.
Poland’s Ministry of the Interior and Administration (MSWiA) has prepared a draft regulation, which according to the published summary would temporarily ban carrying firearms and transporting them unloaded throughout Warsaw on November 11, 2026. For now, this is a draft. So there is still time to read what it actually covers before announcing the latest collapse of the Republic online.
As it happens, I understand the reasoning behind this restriction.
Please put the phone down calmly. There’s no need to unfriend me just yet.
Major ceremonies, public gatherings, people arriving from all over. Someone has to be responsible for keeping it all safe. And it is precisely in this setting that some gun owners decide their personal handgun ought to count as an added benefit. After all, they’re responsible. Law-abiding. They have the paperwork. They know what they’re doing.
No doubt many of them do.
A firearms permit does not, however, appoint you deputy commander of event security. You can have your paperwork in perfect order and a rather less orderly assessment of how indispensable you are. Especially when the internet spends all year telling you that every trip outside is the start of a situation you must prepare for with the right gear, mindset, fitness and one more purchase.
At some point, you stop popping out for bread. You’re conducting a movement to a resupply point in a civilian environment. The bakery hasn’t been briefed. The woman behind the counter still wants to know if you’d like it sliced.
This can be disorienting.
Independence starts to require the right equipment too. Flag, ID, phone, wallet, handgun, a reserve supply of firmly held beliefs. You’re planning a walk around town, but in your head you’ve already assigned the tasks and claimed the most important one. Nobody gave it to you, which only proves you have to rely on yourself.
I imagine this self-appointed readiness is sometimes less reassuring to the people responsible for event security than it is to its owner. He knows his intentions. They’re neatly arranged inside his head, usually with himself in the starring role. The rest of the world doesn’t have access to that presentation.
Neither do I.
That’s why I can understand a temporary restriction on civilian firearms in transit as a precaution. The mere fact that someone legally owns a gun does not settle which rules should apply at a particular event. I can accept that the person planning for an entire city has more to consider than one permit holder’s convenience. Even if that permit holder already has a plan for the entire city. In a comment.
This is usually where history enters the conversation. Our ancestors fought. Our ancestors carried guns. Our ancestors didn’t ask for permission.
Our ancestors did all sorts of things, some of which, thankfully, do not have to be reenacted on every anniversary. We can honor the people who had to fight for their own country while spending the day in a country where, for the moment, we don’t have to. I see that as something of an achievement. Even if it’s harder to get a good photo of it.
Attending a ceremony without a gun does not diminish the achievements of the Polish Legions. I’ve run through it in my head several times. The causal connection has yet to appear.
There is, however, a real inconvenience that a joke about tactical operators won’t solve. According to the summary, the draft covers all of Warsaw, including the transport of unloaded firearms. It would therefore also affect someone who simply wants to move an unloaded firearm in its case, drive across town with it or get to a shooting range, with no connection to the celebrations at all. He might have a perfectly sensible plan for the day. No saving the country. No photos.
I understand why that person would be unhappy. Restrictions have a cost, and someone pays it in their own time and disrupted plans. Questions about the area covered, the timing, public notification and statutory exemptions are reasonable. Article 33 of the Act provides for a temporary ban and exemptions. It is worth knowing what they are, rather than deciding the scope of the law by whoever shouted loudest in the comments.
Despite that inconvenience, I can understand the proposed precaution. I have a much bigger problem with the leap from an inconvenient journey to the conviction that someone’s citizenship has just been erased. You can ask why the entire city is covered without reciting every national disaster in chronological order.
Although I admit the group post loses some of its grandeur without them.
I’d be tempted to start with “as a responsible citizen, I demand…” myself. It’s a very satisfying opening. It immediately sets the terms: I am responsible, and the other side still has to prove it deserves a conversation. What usually follows is a few sentences about common sense, typed in a state that has you pounding the keyboard like a vending machine that’s swallowed your money.
Your composure is best measured, at that point, by the number of exclamation marks.
And yet responsibility should also include the ability to adapt your plans to the situation. Sometimes that means accepting a restriction you find inconvenient. Sometimes it means calmly asking for a better explanation. Either way, it helps to be able to cope with the discovery that the world was not organized as a series of opportunities to confirm how exceptional we are.
That may be the hardest part of the entire training course.
So for November 11, I suggest an exercise that requires no new gear, no qualified instructor and no commemorative patch. Try, just for a moment, not to be a special case. Show up as a participant. Let the people doing their jobs get on with them, without our imaginary supervision.
I’ll start with that last one myself.
I already have a few comments on how they should do it.
#Kałdun