The International League of YouTube Instructors offers no respite, bombarding the Chairman’s watchful mind with an endless avalanche of material. Most online discussions need no commentary: just read them.
Out loud. But not everybody has the imaginary industrial-strength protective kit needed to survive the experience (picture a monitor under a protective blanket, observed from a safe distance in a full Slavic squat) or a welding helmet worthy of an electrical substation (of the sort we imagined in the hull workshop at Gdynia’s Paris Commune Shipyard). So, in the interests of protecting life and limb, I feel obliged to shed some light on the issues being debated lately:
To carry with a round in the chamber, or not? That is the question, although an old Polish saying has already assured us that…if you bring your own, you will not have to beg for someone else’s.
The discussion seems to concern handguns, narrowed down to pistols while leaving the noble revolver out of it. Mention a revolver and I am immediately lost in arguments about chambers, hammers and which way the cylinder turns. The Polish word for that cylinder, bęben, also means a big belly-a coincidence? I think not!-which makes the entire subject feel suspiciously personal. My knowledge of such matters may owe rather too much to Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid. Before long, an argument about one empty chamber has turned into an argument about three. Half the capacity gone, all in the name of certainty. Revolvers raise too many questions for me, so let us assume the discussion has retreated to self-loading pistols.
In rifles, I have seen those yellow and red plastic flags put into the chamber to show that the weapon is unloaded. I still do not understand: if shooters do not trust one another enough to unload their guns, how is another mechanical device supposed to fill that gap in trust? Why do complicated exercises in which students wave guns at one another if the only way to make them safe is to put a piece of yellow plastic in the chamber? Could they not have stayed at home? Or been at work? Another question without an answer.
The first thing YouTube teaches us is the existence of “Conditions”, each followed by a number: Condition Zero, Condition Two, Condition Three, all the way to Condition N+1. As Leopold Kronecker put it, “God made the integers; all else is the work of man.” The manufacturer describes its own firearm in the manual, but apparently only a YouTube instructor can reveal the terminology’s true meaning. The most intriguing of all is “CONDITION ZERO” - („ condition” being an English word for a state, rather than something you put in your hair. The word alone tells us very little: we still need to know which state we mean. Is zero a natural number? That depends on the convention. Which, naturally, is all the encouragement this mathematical digression needs. Enter Instructor Zero , whose name is irresistibly convenient for the joke. The branding promises an entire system of meaning. After a course with Instructor Zero , I fear we may have moved backwards, out of the positive numbers altogether.
In the YouTube universe, the reason for another complication matters less than giving it an English name and a number. Is one more than zero? Is Condition Seven less than Condition Three? Does this work like DEFCON, or the levels in a post-apocalyptic game? If one pistol is in Condition Two and another in Condition Three, are we collectively in Condition Five? Back in my day-a time rightly consigned to history-we used three ordinary Polish terms for different states of readiness. Clearly, we knew nothing. A magazine containing zero rounds could still turn a discussion into a grammatical war. Were they rounds? Cartridges? Cartouches? That reminds me of the abuse I received as a young man at the range-the verbal variety, before your imagination gets carried away-for the command “Load with a ten-round magazine!” Apparently, precision demanded something more like “Load with a thirty-round magazine containing ten rounds!” Such were the grammatical fascists in the organization I served. The Chairman’s adventures with weapons deserve a column of their own. Do not imagine I learned all this by watching YouTube. I have fired more rounds than Natalia Siwiec has had hot dinners.
To the point. I described the groups of people carrying firearms in Poland in my last essay. Officers, whatever we may think of them, are bound by their service’s regulations, regardless of the formation. From what I have seen on YouTube, the Polish police carry their weapons loaded, without a round in the chamber. Officers carry them as their regulations require. I assume services that very rarely use firearms carry them loaded, while those likely to be reacting to an attacker, such as BOR, carry a round chambered. And the super-secret units ( lower your voice) with three-letter abbreviations, depending on the situation. They have more training, they are special forces, they do as they please. When they go out on a (lower your voice) job, I assume it looks exactly like Commando, because Arnold has always been my most rigorous documentary source. Now listen, children: there is a story coming.
A firearm can be UNLOADED - remove the magazine, pull the bolt or slide back, PHYSICALLY check the chamber, tilt the weapon forwards in case something has stuck to the grease on the bolt face, take a clearing shot towards the range backstop or another safe direction, and apply the safety if there is one and it works in that state. On an old Minimi it will not, and you can swear at that safety all you like, but it will not move: that one works differently.
Did I mention the shouting I endured at the range? Magazine, bolt, trigger (or “trigga”).
A firearm can be LOADED -which, in this column’s terminology, is distinguished from UNLOADED and from having a round in the chamber. The vocabulary alone can sustain an argument for hours (there is a ridiculous ninja story coming up)
…and finally. Pay attention:
A firearm can be CHAMBERED -a further distinction from merely being LOADED . At this point, our terminology debate acquires so many competing verbs that I am tempted to invent a new rule of my own: the freshly patented Five-P Principle. No sooner have I invented it than another supposedly ingenious rule suggests itself. Write it down, children; I cannot take all this wisdom to the grave (the newly invented Reverse-Safety Principle).
How terribly complicated.
That leaves civilians. Armed civilians. In the deliberately lopsided arithmetic of this column, 99,999% are sports shooters and 0,001% hold firearms for personal protection. “Sports shooter” is a broad label here: I mean recreational, hobby, collecting and artistic varieties as much as formal competition. Hunters are somewhere in the forest, too busy with ceremonial horns and piles of dead animals to join the internet argument. The personal-protection permit holder, in my gangster-film imagination, wakes beside a horse’s head, finds a headless fish nailed to the door, breaks into a cold sweat at the car ignition, or carries the day’s carpet-wholesale takings in a plastic bag. There cannot be many people living in quite that film. Who in Poland feels permanently threatened with murder-or with being locked in a cellar and forced to read online comments? Enter the police firearms licensing department, the WPA-the institution that, in my argument, sometimes saves people from their own ideas-which I portray here as a cautious gatekeeper. We are in constant touch, naturally.
If someone is fortunate enough to hold such a permit, they can carry their weapon chambered, loaded or unloaded. It makes no difference to my argument, because I put the number of successful armed self-defence cases involving such people in Poland at zero. Nobody has yet shot an attacker with a firearm issued under a personal-protection permit in Poland. Somebody online suggested you were more likely to have a Boeing fall on your head than face a real threat requiring a pistol. Since this column already has a mathematical theme, let us look at the odds.
On 21 December 1988, a Pan Am flight exploded over Lockerbie, killing 243 passengers and crew and 11 people on the ground. The UK had 56 million inhabitants in 1988. 56/11 = 5,090,000. One person in five million was killed by a falling aircraft. In Poland in 2015, ZERO people were shot by civilians with legally held pistols for personal protection. 1/5,000,000 is infinitely greater than zero. (Mathematical mind-bender: add infinity to the argument and the internet discussion can last forever.)
Let us return to the other supposed 99.999 percent. SPORTS shooters, responding to the beeps from a large illuminated electronic timer, yet- PAY ATTENTION-carrying a gun for personal protection, or the prospect of an incident that would justify using a gun. Something in their heads tells them the threat will come from outside, when statistically the greatest threat is themselves and the people around them at the range. The basis for this behaviour is an interpretation of the rules, or the absence of rules, suggesting that “I can carry my sporting firearm because I am on my way to the range.” Perhaps. I am assuming good faith and lawful conduct here; the satire is aimed at the story people build around it.
Now the causal acrobatics begin. Someone transports sporting firearms and argues that another gun is needed to protect the guns already in the bag. How many bus journeys actually end in the imagined ambush? The argument continues nonetheless. A different handgun is reserved for “protection”, surrounded by increasingly specialized equipment and terminology. The holster itself becomes another object of elaborate debate- a separate branch of the same religion).
Then comes the ammunition selected for-a wink and a lowered voice-“protection”. The answer in the parody is an absurd string of impressive words: semi-jacketed FBI Federal explosive-tip caseless P+. The stated aim is to avoid harming bystanders. Naturally, the calibre debate will arrive in the next five minutes. We would hate to endanger Mrs Grażyna coming home from the Lidl sale with her new Kubota slides. Behind the whole performance lies the claim that the gun would only be used in an emergency -which ought to be the starting point of the discussion. We do not normally solve a neighbor’s loud music by shooting them. The gangster-film imagination would at least begin with the headless fish. The leap that worries me is the belief that declaring an emergency makes every other question disappear.
Let me illustrate the argument with a thoroughly absurd thought experiment:
I have received PLN 500 from the 500 Plus programme (more precisely, the government has taken PLN 700 from productive citizens by force, represented by armed policemen, and transferred the money to my unproductive self in exchange for a cross on a ballot paper every four years and a debt for my unborn children). In a drunken rage, I am beating my sixth child because fifteen-year-old Karyna has got pregnant again. A patrol from the State Citizens’ Police arrives and tells me I must not do that. I take this on board and collapse onto the sofa, devastated by my parenting mistake. SUDDENLY! A masked NINJA flies through the fourth-floor window of the flat in Suchedniów. An officer reacts, shouting, STOP! POLISH POLICE! and racks his pistol as the use of force escalates (all in a fraction of a second). The NINJA instantly swings his katana (all right, a wakizashi, let us be realistic) and cuts off the officer’s arm. In a flash of sobriety, I grab the severed limb still clutching its P-64 and fire at the NINJA, recalling my old conscript training with a Nagant. By then he is laying into the other policeman with nunchucks. I kill him with one accurate, if accidental, shot in the back.
I had no firearms permit and was drunk out of my fucking mind (all right, a blood-alcohol level of 0.4% is not drunk!), and I had fourteen convictions for handling stolen goods. BUT I used a gun in an emergency. Because there was a NINJA with a sword. The mayor of Słupsk gave me a medal. Everything is fine. We do not know what the mayor of Słupsk was doing in Suchedniów. Perhaps it had something to do with the police academy, some good publicity and my vote in four years, along with the votes of state-dependent policemen producing no value and falling victim to masked NINJAS in masks. We shall never know.
Unfortunately, in that situation our sports shooter is going to do time. If he uses that super-pistol in his ankle holster, with that Federal P++ hollow-point Black Rhino ammunition, any lawyer with a pulse will, I maintain, argue murderous intent. A dedicated pistol, advance planning for its use, ammunition bought for something other than sport. No scheduled range session that day. Premeditation all the way. An ordinary prosecutor will argue murder, and Polish case law will finish the demolition. To my mind, it is no different from carrying a baseball bat studded with nails in your LPG-converted BMW 520, even if you play in the Pułtusk junior league once a month.
There is one very different situation: a person in a suicidal crisis at a shooting range. That is a real human emergency, not a stage for an internet performance.
[A passage about filming a person in crisis has been omitted.]
So here is my deliberately exaggerated prescription for the endless chambered-or-not debate: find some honest work, give the online argument a rest and begin distinguishing- with whatever help is needed-ordinary life from the action film playing in your head. A quieter imagination might help. Add lukewarm tea and a pair of trainers.
#ThroughTheChairmansEyes