Training is a set of consciously performed activities and processes aimed at improving physical or mental skills.

Physical training leads to adaptation and improves the motor skills required for a particular sport. Life itself is a form of training: we learn to walk, speak, do mathematics, use other languages and acquire all sorts of skills. You can ask anyone who trains a particular discipline plenty of specific questions. The basic ones are: “What are you training?„, „…What are you training for? and “Why are you training this way?„.

The same applies to firearms training.

Many people start in childhood with toys, advancing to air guns, and later-often as a result of contact with the military-dealing with the operation of long guns and machine guns, ending with autocannons and artillery. A very important, actually fundamental concept in the art of training is visualization. Visualization of goals, performance, and the intended final effect.

A boxer punching a bag pictures an opponent; a kenjutsu practitioner cutting through the air imagines an attacking samurai-or perhaps a karate fighter’s nunchaku. A soldier trains in the same way. Firing at a target a hundred meters away from a prone position, he is implicitly shooting at an enemy of the nation, nameless and faceless. He is judged on shot grouping and points. A nine is better than an eight, but behind the target lies the purpose of the exercise: to hit an opponent with a firearm as quickly as possible, from as far away as possible. At later stages, the target becomes more realistic. Combat Figure No. 27, commonly known as “Bolek and Lolek”, represents an enemy machine-gun crew. Popular shooting courses are generally divided into basic and advanced levels. Naturally, those apparently elusive Polish words have been replaced by the English basic and advanced (pronounced BEJSIK / ADWANS in Polish: “I’ve done the BEJSIK; now I’m going on the ADWANS”). With each level, the imagined target becomes clearer and more realistic.

Unfortunately, none of those training models has much to do with the latest displays of artistic marksmanship I have been watching, courtesy of permanent internet access and YOO-TOOB. As someone who cannot shoot and whose doctor has forbidden him ever to touch a gun again, I am always hungry for practical knowledge. The internet is the only relatively safe way for me to stay in contact with firearms. What I am seeing now looks like the beginning of what the experts call the ultraparadoxical phase in Pavlov’s classical typology. I present my observations below in three acts.

Act 1 - Circo Massimo

My attention was caught by an Italian instructor whose videos feature mirrors, balloons and enormous digital watches. Perhaps the display is meant to be read from the next county. Alongside the usual routine, which could have come straight from the glory days of Poland’s Julinek circus school-freestyle trampoline and improvised juggling-his facial expressions deserve a category of their own. The grimacing seems to happen even faster than the shooting. It is an extraordinary performance, and I find myself wondering how much of what I am watching is teaching and how much is theatre. The presentation assembles every possible emblem of martial masculinity: the lumberjack beard, mythological tattoos, amulets, bracelets, mirrored aviators and, of course, the guns. The targets become props in a private action film. The instructor appears to inhabit a world of his own devising, with rules perfectly suited to the skills he has chosen to demonstrate. The number of videos is no substitute for the substance of the lesson. In that world, self-invented shooting disciplines keep their creator permanently at the top of the leaderboard. Once we recognize the theatrical machinery behind the millions of views, it becomes easier to distinguish the spectacle from what a student might actually learn.

What persuaded the Special Forces Command to invite this circus act to provide training is beyond my comprehension. What interests me is the transfer of prestige that followed the visit. He can now say that he has trained Polish special forces. That gives the performance an impressive institutional seal of approval. A fine credential for the next promotional video. But what can the command say? That they went to the circus? That no other training was available? That they expect to transfer something from this spectacle into their own training routine? If so, what does that say about their ability to distinguish useful instruction from a farce? A show at an open day would at least make sense. Perhaps I have misunderstood and entertainment was the whole point. Let us hope so.

Act 2 - Grudziądz by Night

When a police officer at the range shouts “STOP! POLICE!” before firing at a target, we are watching visualization at work.

In the simplest version, we imagine an offender doing something that presents an immediate threat. The officer identifies themselves and calls on the person to stop. In the argument I am making here, that warning represents a great deal more than a shouted phrase: it is an offer of dialogue, a chance to resolve the situation despite the power of the state and the officer’s training and equipment.

Even the second warning- “STOP OR I’LL SHOOT!”-continues that dialogue. It offers a chance to avoid the consequence. It also places responsibility for the next decision on the person being addressed. The situation demands a rapid understanding of what refusing the warning could mean.

The use of lethal force without warning remains morally contentious. My point here is philosophical: a society that separates public authority from religious authority, and divides the powers of the state, should be uneasy about death being imposed without a trial. In the Christian language that shaped so much European culture, a warning leaves room for repentance and a change of course. These are the values I read into a seemingly simple cry: “POLICE! STOP OR I’LL SHOOT!”

How, then, are we supposed to interpret drills that go straight from complete stillness to a burst of shooting at a target almost within arm’s reach? What situation does the shooter imagine? What is happening in their mind?

A police officer, including a tactical officer, normally enters an incident with some idea of what is happening. If the call describes a violent emergency-say, “someone has attacked a relative”-there is at least some context. An incident witnessed unexpectedly also unfolds over time. Even when an officer reaches for a weapon and shouts “POLICE!”, there is-or, I would argue, there should be -a conscious decision about the use of force. An immensely difficult decision, perhaps the hardest of a lifetime. How does that compare with standing relaxed in front of a target and suddenly firing because an electronic timer beeps?

Consider the civilian version. Even a home-invasion fantasy has a sequence of events: glass breaks, you wake up, you work out what is happening. Perhaps Sasha Igorovich has appeared at the door-  because, in this absurd scenario, you sold him counterfeit transferable rubles -but none of it happens outside time. Even if Volodya Vlasov (not his real name) and a squad of action-film veterans suddenly storm your eighth-floor flat, the scene still has to unfold. Real life does not start and stop at the command of a shooting timer.

Other possibilities:

A contract killing -in the gangster-film version, the victim never gets a fair warning or a neatly arranged duel. That hardly explains the drill either.

A bank robbery -you are standing in a queue when a stranger drops a pistol. In your private action movie, this is your cue to become the hero, all while trying to withdraw your savings from SKOK Wołomin before the next financial scandal consumes them. You have stopped a robbery.

Except you have not. You have mistaken another gun owner for a robber. That is the problem with a fantasy that supplies its own certainty. Even when a scene resembles a robbery from a film, complete with masked men yelling, “Everybody on the floor!” recognizing a threat and deciding what to do are not the same thing as responding to a beep. The target on the range does not explain the judgment being trained.

A business dispute -you visit a supplier, put the cash on the table, and then: SUDDENLY! The meeting turns into a gangster-film showdown. If this is a routine hazard of your trade, perhaps a change of profession deserves consideration. In what world does a friendly discussion of coin collections become an execution scene? I have seen it in films. It is a curious model on which to base the rest of one’s life.

The only explanation I have managed to come up with after weeks of thinking about it-remember, I have a large head; these things take place on an industrial scale-is that the imagined shooter has already decided to kill before the encounter begins. That is why the title invokes a sicario: a hired killer. It is a disturbing conclusion about the fantasy behind the drill, not a scenario to imitate. BANG! BANG! BANG! SCAN! MORE BANGS! Only when the decision has already been made does the performance begin to make sense to me.

Then there is the familiar fashion known as “appendix carry” (naturally, we need the English term for this). I prefer the literal Polish rendering, “worm-appendage carry” -although my own proposed term, “ballistic bollocks”, has so far failed to catch on. The visual symbolism is hard to miss. It also seems to assume that everybody lives in shorts and a T-shirt. Perhaps that explains the disastrous business meeting. Clothes, body shape and a growing collection of accessories complicate the picture. The Kałdun crowd may have some practical reservations. Add a custom ZEV slide and enough optical equipment to furnish a small observatory, and the gulf between the polished demonstration and ordinary life becomes part of the joke. The person on the other end of the fantasy is cast as a victim before the performance even begins.

The display has become a ritual of exaggerated masculinity: the gear, the pose and the promise of instant mastery. In the fantasy, defeating every other man would settle the question of status once and for all. On the range, however, an impressive performance can remain entirely self-contained. Repeating it may feel satisfying without answering the more awkward question: what real ability is this supposed to develop?

Act 3 - Transmarginal Inhibition 

A further evolution of the ritual is the popular “vehicle work”, staged around a wreck brought onto the range. The advertisements practically write themselves: “Come and train on the car„, „ Car day next week„, „ Fundamentals of vehicle work”, and, inevitably, “Dynamic multi-vector vehicular firearms techniques in tactically shaken environments.” The more absurd the title, the harder it becomes to work out what the course is actually teaching.

These sessions turn a wrecked car into the stage for another imagined firefight. My objection is not that a vehicle can never be relevant to training, but that the advertised spectacle often leaves the supposed real-world context unexplained. Calling something military does not make that context appear.

The driver’s role raises further questions: the performance often seems to forget that somebody must still operate the vehicle. Historical incidents also show how much can depend on the problem of movement rather than an impressive shooting sequence. Consider the planning difficulties surrounding the famous Operation Arsenal, the 1943 Warsaw operation to rescue prisoners from German custody. A historical digression, perhaps, but a useful reminder that a scenario contains more than the moment a shot is fired.

VIP protection teams hardly explain this sort of training either. The imagined streets of Medellín belong to a different sort of scenario: violent ambushes involving weapons such as the Ingram 11 . You can see the cinematic version in the “documentary” Narcos (worth watching on Netflix during a break from YOO-TOOB, as primary training material, obviously). Protection services such as Poland’s BOR or the Secret Service also have armored vehicles when their work calls for them. If you have no armored car, then by this magnificent logic you are too poor and insignificant for anyone to want you dead, and therefore have no need for shooting lessons. Of course, the action-film imagination can always invent another ambush on the way out to walk the dog. And if your dog needs taking out or it will shit on the carpet, well-anything is possible.

The only scenario I can make out in this training is a gangster fantasy about attacking traffic police. Even the target arrangement seems borrowed from that imaginary film. The rest is a reenactment of Heat, with Robert De Niro and a still-slim Val Kilmer as the heavily armed gangsters. Speaking of automatic weapons: I do not mean to nitpick, but what is all this speed shooting for? Professional services have access to automatic weapons. If you are trying to imitate one with frantic trigger work, presumably you do not have one. Which raises the question of why this performance is supposed to be essential to you. A digression: when you see a car on the range, quietly head home, have some lukewarm tea and relax. Nobody is shooting at you. And if somebody really did, the outcome would not necessarily resemble your favorite film. What two or three bearded adults in baseball caps, civilian clothes and carrying rifles are doing in a stationary wreck on a shooting range in midsummer is, once again, beyond my comprehension. Like so many things.

To sum up: the Italian instructor’s performance strikes me as a contest between theatrical speed and an increasingly elaborate imaginary world. The vehicle drills raise a different concern: people without sound foundations interpreting YOO-TOOB videos, then teaching techniques their hobbyist audience is unlikely ever to use. In my view, the most tangible result is needless danger to instructors and students alike. Common sense is in the same condition as the imaginary driver of that vehicle: dead.

#TheChairman